21/4Cr-1Mo thick wall ethylene cracking furnace tube welding process

Key words: furnace tube, welding process, temper embrittlement

【Abstract】The welding process test and joint performance test of Cr-1Mo furnace tube were carried out. The proper welding specifications and heat treatment tempering parameters were selected. The joint was subjected to temper embrittlement sensitivity test, and the embrittlement temperature increment was much lower than that. Control indicators.
The convection section of the 60,000 t/a ethylene cracking furnace of Beijing Yanshan Petrochemical Co., Ltd., which is manufactured by our factory, is all imported from Japan. One of the furnace tubes is Wpe16.jpg (868 bytes) Cr-1Mo has a specification of 168 mm×27 mm, a design pressure of 21.9 MPa, and a design temperature of 516 °C, which is a condition of high temperature and high pressure. Although our factory has many years of experience in manufacturing the convection section of the cracking furnace, the materials are generally carbon steel, and the wall thickness is within 12 mm. For the welding of high temperature and high pressure furnace tube materials, more researches at home and abroad are Cr5Mo and 12CrMoV, but for thick walls. Wpe17.jpg (868 bytes) Welding of Cr-1Mo furnace tubes is less studied. In order to reasonably determine its welding line energy, preheating temperature and post-weld heat treatment system, it was discussed.

1 Welding method and selection of welding materials <br> The chemical composition of the convection section of the cracking furnace is shown in Table 1. The mechanical properties are σb=625 MPa, σs=498 MPa, ψ=44.1%, HV=193, ak=257 J. The welding position on the frame is horizontally fixed and obstacles, and the appearance of the weld is very demanding. The residual height of the weld is not more than 1 mm, the height difference of the welding wave is not more than 0.5 mm, the residual height of the back is 0.5 mm, and the weld is 100% X-ray flawed. The manual TIG welding is more suitable. The ASME SA355 is used. The TIG-2GM grade low alloy steel wire produced by the -92 standard has the chemical composition shown in Table 1.

Table 1 Chemical composition%

element C Si Mn Cr Mo S P
Furnace tube 0.130 0.250 0.600 2.270 1.030 0.003 0.007
Welding wire 0.085 0.302 0.780 2.240 1.060 0.008 0.005


2 Welding process test and analysis

2.1 Preheating temperature test Wpe14.jpg (868 bytes) Cr-1Mo steel tube with a wall thickness of 27 mm, subjected to oblique Y-type restraint crack resistance test at normal temperature and different preheating temperatures. Test welding specification E = 10.2 kJ/cm (I=110 A, U=14 V, v =9 cm/min), after the test weld was placed for 48 h, the surface of the weld was examined by staining and the section was observed with a low power optical microscope. The surface and section crack rates are shown in Table 2.

Table 2 Crack resistance test results

Preheating temperature / °C Surface breakage rate /% Section crack rate /%
Normal temperature 100.0 100.0
100 70.5 83.7
150 0.0 43.5
200 0.0 0.0
250 0.0 0.0


the experiment shows, Wpe15.jpg (868 bytes) The cold cracking tendency of Cr-1Mo steel is relatively large. With the increase of preheating temperature, the joint resistance to cold cracking is improved. When Tr ≥ 200 °C, the cold cracks are all eliminated. Therefore, the preheating temperature before welding is selected at about 200 °C to meet the crack resistance requirements.

2.2 Welding line energy

It can be seen from the previous test that when the preheating temperature is 200 °C and the welding line energy E is about 10 kJ/cm, the weld seam does not crack, and the E value at this time should be the critical value (lower limit value). From the point of view of molding, under the specification, the root base and the second and third layers are transitioned, the full position is well formed, and the reverse surface height is also within the control index, while the other weld layer specifications are in the joint to obtain a good comprehensive mechanics. Under the premise of performance, you should choose as much as possible to improve production efficiency. Therefore, a line energy upper limit must be determined. Two options are used for this test: a 110 kJ/cm specification primer transition, a 20 kJ/cm gauge fill and a cover. 210 kJ/cm specification base transition, 30 kJ/cm gauge fill and cover. The samples of both solutions were tempered at 710 °C for 2 h. Check the normal temperature mechanical properties of the joint and the impact toughness at -50 °C. The joint tensile strength at room temperature is 570 ~ 580 MPa, and it does not crack after 90 ° cold bending. The comparison of the impact energy at -50 °C between the weld zone, the fusion zone and the heat affected zone of the welding specimens of the two schemes is shown in Fig. 1. Under the same heat treatment conditions, the reduction of the solder layer and the increase of the line energy result in a decrease in joint toughness. This is mainly because the cooling rate is slow after the increase of E, resulting in coarse grains in the superheated zone and poor toughness. Wpe15.jpg (868 bytes) Cr-1Mo steel has a strong tendency to temper embrittlement, which has a large loss of joint toughness. Therefore, in order not to excessively increase the plastic-brittle transition temperature by the increase of E, the toughness of the joint is lost, so 20 kJ/cm is selected as the upper limit of the welding specification.

Figure 1 Effect of line energy on toughness

2.3 Post-weld heat treatment specification [1] pointed out that for Cr-Mo steel, the tempering parameter [P] varies from 20.0 to 20.6, but for a specific weldment, there is an optimum [P] value. . For wall thickness 27 mm Wpe15.jpg (868 bytes) After the post-weld heat treatment of Cr-1Mo furnace tube, the [P] value is taken as the lower limit of 20.0 and the heat preservation is for 2 h. According to the tempering parameter calculation formula, there are:

[P]=T(20+lgt)×10-3 (1)

Where T is the tempering temperature, K; t is the holding time, h. From the formula (1), T = 710 °C. In order to further understand the influence of the tempering specification on the joint performance, the welding samples of the above scheme 1 were tempered at 650 ° C, 710 ° C and 760 ° C for 2 h, and then the performance test was carried out.
In order to investigate the influence of [P] on the impact toughness of -50 °C, the V-notch impact test of -50 °C was performed on the heat affected zone of the sample at 650 °C, 710 °C and 760 °C. 2.

Figure 2 Effect of heat treatment temperature on toughness

2.4 [P] Effect on weld strength The joint is subjected to room temperature stretching and 425 °C high temperature short-time tensile test. The results are shown in Table 3. The tempering parameter [P] is taken as 20.0, that is, the tempering temperature is 710 °C. It is more appropriate.

Table 3 joint temperature and high temperature short-term performance

Tempering temperature / °C Σs/σb at room temperature Σs/σb at 425 °C
650 612/436 507/359
710 540/411 485/308
760 538/402 475/284


3 joint temper embrittlement sensitivity test
3.1 Weld metal correlation coefficient X, J coefficient is an important indicator to measure the tempering sensitivity of Cr-Mo steel. The literature [2] pointed out that in order to ensure a good resistance to temper embrittlement of the weld, the X coefficient of the weld metal is required to be less than 25×10-6, and the J factor is less than 200. To this end, chemical composition analysis was performed on elements closely related to temper embrittlement, and the results are shown in Table 4.

Table 4 weld temper embrittlement sensitive element content%

element Si Mn P As Sn Sb
content 0.37 0.75 0.006 0.000 4 0.000 9 0.001


The data from the table can be obtained:

X=(10P+5Sb+4Sn+As)0.01=0.000 008 (2)

J=(Si+Mn)(P+Sn)10 000=84.5 (3)

Both values ​​are below the control index, indicating that the selected welding material is sufficient to meet the requirements of tempering and embrittlement resistance.

3.2 The temper embrittlement evaluation test evaluation method uses Socal No. 1 step cold curve [2], see Figure 3. By step cooling treatment, the material is stepped through the embrittlement temperature to cause accelerated embrittlement conditions, so that the material embrittlement amount is larger in a shorter time.

14-3.gif (3362 bytes)

Figure 3 step cooling treatment (SC) curve

Wpe18.jpg (868 bytes) The plastic-brittle transition temperature of temper embrittlement of Cr-1Mo material should meet the following requirements:

vTr54+KΔvTr54≤38 °C (4)

Where ΔvTr54=vTr'54-vTr54, vTr54 is the transition temperature at 54 J after the tempering treatment (SR); vTr54 is the tempering treatment plus step cooling treatment (SR+SC) after 54 J impact energy The transition temperature; K is the enhancement factor, which is taken as 2.0.
Welded samples with high temperature tempering (SR) at 710 °C for 2 h and tempered and then cold-treated (SR+SC) samples were used for welds and heat-affected zones at 20-60 °C. The notched impact test, the plastic-brittle transition temperature curve is shown in Figure 4 and Figure 5. It can be seen that the temperature of the impact energy of the weld and the heat-affected zone SR is -56 °C and -54 °C, and the temperature increment before and after the weld embrittlement is about 5 °C, so Tr54+2ΔvTr54=-46 °C, so the heat influence The temperature increment before and after the embrittlement is about 8 °C, then Tr54+2ΔvTr54=-38 °C, both of which are far below the control index.

14-4.gif (3977 bytes)

Figure 4 Transition temperature curve before and after weld embrittlement

14-5.gif (3588 bytes)

Fig.5 Transition temperature curve before and after embrittlement in heat affected zone

4 Conclusion

1 For thick fireplace tube welding, pre-weld preheating is necessary. When the preheating temperature is controlled at about 200 °C, cold cracking can be effectively prevented. 2 For the welding of the tube tube horizontally fixed and the obstacle position, the lower limit of the welding line energy is controlled at about 10 kJ/cm, and a satisfactory weld root formation can be obtained. For the filling bead and the cover surface, as the upper limit of the line energy increases, the weld layer decreases, the mechanical properties of the joint at room temperature change are not obvious, and the impact toughness at -50 °C shows a significant downward trend. In order to ensure reliable fracture toughness of the joint, the line energy control is suitable at 20 kJ/cm. 3 thick fireplace tube welded joints at room temperature and 425 °C high temperature short-term tensile strength, with the increase in tempering temperature have significantly decreased. The impact energy at -50 °C is shown at 710 °C, ie [P]=20.0. To ensure the comprehensive mechanical properties of the joint, the reasonable heat treatment specification is [P]=20.0, ie tempering temperature 710 °C, heat preservation 2 h. 4The TGS-2CM welding wire is selected, the embrittlement sensitivity coefficient of the weld is lower than the control index, the welding line energy is controlled at 10~20 kJ/cm, and the tempering parameter [P] is 20.0, the weld and heat affected zone The plastic-brittle transition temperature is low, the embrittlement temperature increment is small after the joint cooling treatment, the joint toughness is large, and the anti-tempering ability is strong. Therefore, the safety margin is large at high temperature, and brittle fracture does not occur.

About the author : Huang Yiluo (1969-), male, bachelor of engineering, welding engineer.
Author : Maoming Petrochemical Company, Maoming, Guangdong 525024, China

references:
[1] Zeng Le. Handbook of Modern Welding Technology [M]. Shanghai: Shanghai Science and Technology Press, 1991.785-786.
[2] Qi Shubai. The technical collection of hot wall hydrogenation reactor manufacturing technology [C]. Beijing: Sinopec Beijing Planning Office, 1986.152.


Stone Garden Decor

There are many ways to design stone carvings, among which the sink carving, also known as "line carving", is an artwork using the "water mill sink flower" carving method. This kind of carving method absorbs traditional techniques such as Chinese painting and meaning, overlapping, line modeling, scattered point perspective, etc. After the stone is polished by plane processing, it traces the pattern text, and then carves lines according to the drawing, with the thickness and depth of the lines, using shadows to reflect the three-dimensional sense. Most of these products are used for exterior wall surface decoration of buildings, with strong artistry.

Stone Garden Decor,Cast Stone Garden Decor,Cast Stone Garden Decor Fountains,Outdoor Stone Garden Decor

The universe in the stone is great , https://www.zdsarts.com